5 Best Catchers Mitts

Choosing a new catcher’s mitt can seem like a daunting process considering how many mitts there are to choose from. You have to take into consideration the size of the mitt, the padding, how comfortable it is to wear, how easy it is to break-in, and the price. Keep in mind that while there are plenty of affordable catcher’s mitts available on the market, you do not necessarily want to choose the cheapest mitt.

Your mitt is what enables to catch incoming balls and scoop them up off the ground to stop the opposing team from scoring a run. Therefore, you want the best mitt possible, which means spending the money to get it. Fortunately, the list below provides you with some of the best catcher’s mitts available on the market that best suit a variety of budgets, and each provides its own list of potential advantages and drawbacks. However, you should find your purchase decision far easier thanks to this comprehensive review.

Wilson A2000 Baseball Catcher’s Mitt
All Star CM3000SBT Catchers Mitt
Mizuno World Win 34″ Catcher’s Mitt Gxc75 Deep Ii
Rawlings Renegade Series Catchers Mitt
Akadema AGC98 Prodigy Series Glove
Rating: 5/5
Rating: 4.7/5
Rating: 5/5
Rating: 4.8/5
Rating: 4.6/5
Material: Pro-Stock Leather
Material: Japanese Tanned Steer Hide Leather
Material: Tanned Retro Leather
Material: Oil-tanned, full-grain leather
Material: Steerhide Pocket, AkademaLyte Leather Back
Break-In Ready: No
Break-In Ready: No, but fast break-in
Break-In Ready: No, but fast break-in
Break-In Ready: Yes
Break-In Ready: No
Size: 33″
Size: 33.5″
Size: 34″
Size: 31.5″ and 32.5″
Size: 32″
Cost: $$
Cost: $$$
Cost: $
Cost: $
Cost: $
  • Wilson A2000 Baseball Catcher’s Mitt
  • Rating: 5/5
  • Material: Pro-Stock Leather
  • Break-In Ready: No
  • Size: 33″
  • Cost: $$
  • All Star CM3000SBT Catchers Mitt
  • Rating: 4.7/5
  • Material: Japanese Tanned Steer Hide Leather
  • Break-In Ready: No, but fast break-in
  • Size: 33.5″
  • Cost: $$$
  • Mizuno World Win 34″ Catcher’s Mitt Gxc75 Deep Ii
  • Rating: 5/5
  • Material: Tanned Retro Leather
  • Break-In Ready: No, but fast break-in
  • Size: 34″
  • Cost: $
  • Rawlings Renegade Series Catchers Mitt
  • Rating: 4.8/5
  • Material: Oil-tanned, full-grain leather
  • Break-In Ready: Yes
  • Size: 31.5″ and 32.5″
  • Cost: $
  • Akadema AGC98 Prodigy Series Glove
  • Rating: 4.6/5
  • Material: Steerhide Pocket, AkademaLyte Leather Back
  • Break-In Ready: No
  • Size: 32″
  • Cost: $

1. Wilson A2000 Baseball Catcher’s Mitt

1The Wilson A2000 Baseball Catcher’s Mitt is an incredible mitt for all the right reasons. The mitt features a long-lasting quality and durability that is hard to beat. Considering that Wilson is a well-known brand among baseball fans, it is not hard to see why this particular glove is among the top 5 best catcher’s mitts available. Although the mitt does come with a somewhat higher price tag of $199.95 to $249.95 based on the color and size you choose, it is well worth the purchase.

The mitt, which is available in either black or blonde and black has the following features:

  • Half-moon webbing
  • Extended palm to make ball catching and scooping easier
  • Pattern similar to some of the most popular MLB mitts
  • Specialized DriLex Lining along the wrist to help keep your hand cool and dry

The Wilson A2000 Baseball Catcher’s Mitt is available in a 33-inch and a 34-inch size to accommodate adults with larger or smaller hands. The material of the mitt is a Pro Stock Leather, which provides it with the longevity needed to withstand a beating. One potential drawback is the fact that the mitt is very stiff, so it may take you a bit to break it in. However, with a 5-star rating, it is safe to say that customers have been pretty happy with this mitt overall. One customer commented on the glove saying, “It does take a very long time to break-in, but well worth the effort.”

2. All Star CM3000SBT Catchers Mitt

2The All Star CM3000SBT Catchers Mitt is certainly the priciest mitt on this list, but considering that it is crafted to perfection, it is certainly worth it, especially if you want a long-lasting, high-quality glove. The thing is, you can either purchase a cheap mitt that you will end up having to replace perhaps several times throughout the year, or you can buy an expensive mitt that is sure to last for years to come.

This mitt provides the following features and benefits:

  • Japanese tanned steer hide leather
  • Fast, easy break-in
  • Extended life
  • Soft leather pocket that provides comfort and reduced sting when catching the ball
  • Extended pocket to ensure easier ball pickup and catching

Visually speaking, this glove is a sight to behold. Its blonde and block coloration make it look just as good if not better than something a pro baseball player would be proud to wear. In fact, this particular mitt is a go-to mitt for many professional baseball players. The fact that this mitt comes nearly ready to use straight out of the box is just one of the reasons why its design accommodates more serious ball players.

Overall, the All Star CM3000SBT Catchers Mitt has a rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars with the majority of customers having nothing but positive things to say about it. For instance, one customer is quoted as saying, “I personally think that this is the best catchers glove on the market.” Of course, there are some potential drawback with this mitt. One customer who did not share the same sentiments as the majority of the customers said, “this has very little padding and hurts when you catch with it.” However, with the majority believing that this glove is well worth the price, it certainly deserves a closer look.

3. Mizuno World Win 34 Catcher’s Mitt

3If you are looking for something that is a little easier on your wallet, look no further than that Mizuno World Win 34” Catcher’s Mitt. This particular mitt does not require you to take out a second mortgage, amputate a limb, or sell your soul. It is a quality mitt for the price and offers several benefits for any baseball lover. Whether you consider yourself entry-level or a seasoned pro, this mitt is nothing to bat an eye at.

This mitt offers the following benefits:

  • Tanned retro leather for durability and strength
  • Easy break in thanks to softer material
  • ParaShock finger channels to help absorb shock of catching the ball to reduce stress on the hand

This pro-sized mitt is available in a 34-inch size and features a blonde and black look that is visually stunning. The palm pad ensures that your hand does not take the brunt of the ball’s impact when performing your duties as a catcher. Since this mitt comes out of the box in near game-ready condition, you can enjoy the benefits and overall performance of this glove immediately rather than having to take the time to focus on breaking it in.

Customers seem ultimately pleased with this glove, which is why it boasts a 5-star rating. One customer raved about the benefits of the glove by saying, “Break in period was effortless, great feel and balance.” Overall, there did not seem to be any complaints from customers aside from one who said, “the lacing on one broke during the first game.” However, the customer went on to report that Mizuno was replacing the glove and the customer did not have to spend any money out-of-pocket for the replacement.

4. Rawlings Renegade Series Catchers Mitt

4The Rawlings Renegade Series Catchers Mitt is yet another budget-friendly mitt with several benefits. In fact, it is the most budget-friendly on this list. This glove is available in a 31.5-inch and a 32.5-inch size, which means it is certainly for an adult with a bit smaller of a hand compared to some of the other gloves. However, it is within the range of standard sized catcher’s mitts. One benefit of this glove is that you can purchase it for either right-handed throw or left-handed throw. Keep in mind that you will pay a little more if you opt for a left-handed throw.

This particular mitt offers the following benefits:

  • Visually appealing black features
  • Roomy opening above the wrist for added comfort
  • Palm and finger pads to reduce the sting of ball impact
  • Closed web and a deep pocket to allow for better ball control, catch, and scoop
  • 20% player break-in

If you are looking for a glove that you can play from the minute it arrives on your doorstep, this is the glove for you. The full-grain leather material provides this mitt with the durability needed to withstand several hours, days, weeks, months, and perhaps even years of gameplay. Overall, this glove has received 4.8 out of 5 stars and customers have said great things about it such as, “Really good product. Exactly as described,” and “Very impressed with the quality. This is a very well-made glove.” That is not to say that this glove is without its drawbacks. Some customers felt the glove was a bit on the small side so it is best to ensure that the sizing of this glove is right for your hand.

5. Akadema AGC98 Prodigy Series Glove

5Yet another mitt available at the lower end of the budget spectrum, you can purchase the Akadema AGC98 Prodigy Series Glove. The price listed is for a right-handed throw mitt. If you wish to purchase the left-handed throw mitt, it too is available. This glove offers a wide range of features including:

  • Deep pocket to help you capture the ball
  • Spiral web lock for better ball control
  • Open back for breathability to keep your hand cool
  • Praying Mantis style with two additional “finger hammocks” for firmer positioning of the hand
  • Shock absorption to reduce the sting of ball impact

This mitt also features a Grasp-Clasp wrist that ensures a comfortable and secure fit, which is of the utmost importance out of a quality glove. Part of what makes this mitt so incredible is that it was designed by MLB hall of famer, Gary Carter. If you are going to play with a quality mitt, why not play with one designed by a player that knows a thing or two about the overall design of a good mitt?

This mitt boasts a rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars with customers providing generally great feedback. One customer went as far as to say, “The glove is very good, especially for the price point.” Keep in mind that the drawback of this glove is that it is not game ready. You will need to spend the time to break-in this glove. If you are seeking a mitt that you can play with immediately, this might not be the glove for you. However, if you are willing to take the time to get this mitt game ready, it is well worth the purchase price.

Final Thoughts

Each of the mitts featured on this list provide you with incredible benefits. They each accommodate varying budgets, which helps make your purchase decision that much easier. Whether you are looking to spend less for a quality mitt that might require a bit of break-in work or you are willing to spend a high-end price for a glove that is sure to last and game ready, you are sure to find what it is you need. Make sure you check out the youth catcher’s mitt reviews as well as our fastpitch catcher’s mitt reviews.