250 Christmas This or That Questions for Parties Filled With Joy and Laughter

Christmas is full of cozy moments, festive traditions, delicious treats, and joyful chaos, which makes it the perfect time to play This or That! Whether you’re hosting a party, planning a classroom activity, gathering with family, or just looking to spark fun conversations, these questions are easy, fast, and always entertaining.

🎯 How to Play

1. Read each pair of options.

2. Everyone picks the one they prefer.

3. No explanations needed… unless you want to debate it 😉.Want to switch things up mid-game? Swap in a round of Christmas would you rather questions for bigger laughs and even harder choices.

Have fun, and enjoy these 250 Christmas This or That Questions, organized into numbered categories for easy use!

🍪 Christmas Food & Drink This or That (1–20)

1. Hot Cocoa or Eggnog

2. Gingerbread Cookies or Sugar Cookies

3. Candy Canes or Chocolate Santas

4. Ham or Turkey

5. Mashed Potatoes or Sweet Potato Casserole

6. Stuffing or Gravy

7. Pie or Cake

8. Peppermint Bark or Fudge

9. Homemade Treats or Store-bought Snacks

10. Cookies and Milk or Cookies and Hot Cocoa

11. Roast Dinner or Casual Buffet

12. Holiday Brunch or Holiday Dinner

13. Turkey Leg or White Meat

14. Marshmallows in Cocoa or Whipped Cream on Cocoa

15. Fruitcake or No Fruitcake

16. Sweet Sides or Savory Sides

17. Leftovers Next Day or Fresh Meal Only

18. Traditional Recipes or New Holiday Recipes

19. Hot Cocoa or Mulled Cider

20. Dessert First or Dinner First

🎁 Gifts & Giving This or That (21–40)

21. Wish-List Gifts or Surprise Gifts

22. One Big Gift or Several Small Gifts

23. Handmade Gifts or Store-Bought Gifts

24. Stocking Gifts or Wrapped Gifts

25. Gift Cards or Cash Gifts

26. Secret Santa or Gift Exchange

27. Shopping Early or Last Minute Shopping

28. Online Shopping or In-Store Shopping

29. Practical Gifts or Fun Gifts

30. Gifts for Adults or Gifts for Kids

31. Books or Gadgets

32. Cozy Gifts or Funny Gifts

33. Matching Gifts or Unique Gifts

34. Wrapping with Ribbons or Minimal Wrapping

35. Personalized Gifts or Generic Gifts

36. Giving Experiences or Giving Physical Gifts

37. Gifts for Pets or No Pet Gifts

38. Gift Wrapping Party or Gift Wrapping Alone

39. One Gift Each or Many Gifts Each

40. Opening Gifts One-by-One or Opening All at Once

🎬 Christmas Movies & Music This or That (41–60)

41. Classic Movies or Modern Holiday Movies

42. Animated Christmas Film or Live-Action Christmas Film

43. Watching Movies on Christmas Eve or Christmas Day

44. Movie Marathon or One Movie Only

45. “Home Alone” or “Elf”

46. Christmas Rom-Com or Family Christmas Movie

47. Watching New Movies or Rewatching Old Favorites

48. Couch and Pajamas or Theater Outing

49. Christmas Carols or Holiday Pop Songs

50. Traditional Carols or Modern Covers

51. Choir Music or Acoustic Music

52. Loud Festive Music or Soft Holiday Tunes

53. Music All December or Music Only Christmas Week

54. Singing Carols or Listening Only

55. Christmas Playlist or Random Songs Mix

56. Holiday Songs Only or Mix with Regular Songs

57. Karaoke Christmas or Quiet Christmas

58. Christmas Concert or Holiday Movie Night

59. Radio Holiday Station or Custom Playlist

60. Music During Dinner or Music After Dinner

❄️ Winter & Holiday Vibes This or That (61–80)

61. Snowy Christmas or Tropical Christmas

62. Real Snow or Fake Snow Décor

63. Cozy Fireplace or Heated Blanket and Movie

64. Winter Cabin or City Lights Christmas

65. Snowstorm Outside or Warm Indoors

66. Snow Angels or Snowball Fights

67. Sledding or Ice Skating

68. Winter Hikes or Indoor Cozy Day

69. Warm Cocoa or Hot Tea

70. Wool Sweater or Fleece Hoodie

71. Boots or Cozy Slippers

72. Gloves or Mittens

73. Snowflakes Décor or Icicle Lights

74. Rustic Holiday Look or Glam Holiday Look

75. Fresh Pine Scent or Holiday Candle Scent

76. Holiday Lights All Around or Simple Décor

77. Cozy Blankets or Festive Blankets

78. Snowy Mornings or Snowy Nights

79. Winter Sunrise or Winter Sunset

80. Snowy Night Walk or Indoor Movie Night

🧑‍🎄 Family, Friends & Celebration Style This or That (81–100)

81. Big Family Gathering or Small Cozy Gathering

82. Matching Pajamas or Individual Outfits

83. Secret Santa with Friends or Gift Exchange with Family

84. Family Game Night or Family Movie Night

85. Homemade Dinner or Takeout Christmas Feast

86. Family Photos or No Photos

87. Opening Gifts Early Morning or Opening Gifts Afternoon

88. Cookies and Milk Tradition or Hot Cocoa Tradition

89. Make New Traditions or Stick with Old Traditions

90. Christmas at Home or Christmas Away

91. Baking and Decorating or Watching Movies and Relaxing

92. Cooking Together or One Person Cooks

93. Loud and Lively Dinner or Calm and Peaceful Dinner

94. Long Christmas Dinner or Light Snacks and Desserts

95. Gifts for Everyone or Gifts Only for Kids

96. Breakfast Together or Dinner Together

97. Holiday Cards or Holiday Text Messages

98. Decorating Together or Decorating Alone

99. Holiday Crafts or Watching Christmas Movies

100. Midnight Celebration or Daytime Celebration

🎉 Parties, Games & Holiday Events This or That (101–120)

If your group enjoys a little friendly disagreement along with the laughs, you can also mix in Christmas debate questions to spark lively conversations and playful arguments.

101. Ugly Sweater Party or Elegant Holiday Party

102. Cookie Decorating Party or Gift Wrapping Party

103. Secret Santa or White Elephant

104. Holiday Karaoke or Holiday Dance Party

105. Board Games or Card Games

106. Movie Marathon Party or Game Night Party

107. Indoor Party or Outdoor Winter Event

108. Hot Cocoa Bar or Dessert Table

109. Potluck Dinner or Catered Meal

110. Matching Outfits or Festive Variety Outfits

111. Themed Party or Casual Party

112. Late Night Snacks or Early Dinner

113. Photo Booth or Craft Table

114. Gift-Wrapping Race or Cookie Decorating Race

115. Sing-Along or Dance-Along

116. Karaoke or Trivia Games

117. Snowman Building or Snowball Fights

118. Carol Singing or Storytelling

119. Holiday Crafts or Holiday Baking

120. Party Games or Chill Conversation

🧸 Kids, School & Holiday Activities This or That (121–140)

121. Classroom Gift Exchange or No Gift Exchange

122. Holiday Crafts or Holiday Coloring Pages

123. Watching Holiday Cartoons or Reading Christmas Stories

124. Pajama Day at School or Festive Sweater Day

125. Decorating Classroom Tree or Decorating Class Lights Only

126. Candy Canes or Stickers

127. Hot Cocoa or Juice Boxes

128. Holiday Movie Day or Holiday Game Day

129. Gift for Teacher or Treats for Class

130. Ornament Making or Card Making

131. Holiday Storytime or Holiday Sing-Along

132. Recess in Snow or Indoor Games

133. Secret Santa Among Students or No Gift Exchange

134. Holiday Quiz or Holiday Drawing Contest

135. Festive Door Decoration or Hallway Decorations

136. Sharing Family Traditions or Sharing Holiday Recipes

137. Gift for Class or Gift for Teacher

138. Winter Crafts or Holiday Baking

139. Group Activities or Individual Activities

140. Holiday Snacks or Regular Snacks

🌍 Travel, Vacation & Holiday Setting This or That (141–150)

If you love exploring global traditions, add Christmas around the world trivia questions answers to inspire travel-themed banter and cultural curiosity.

141. Staycation at Home or Holiday Travel

142. Road Trip or Flight Trip

143. Snowy Mountains or Warm Beach

144. Visiting Family or Hosting Family

145. Small Town Christmas or Big City Christmas

146. Hotel Stay or Home Comfort

147. Shopping Abroad or Shopping Locally

148. Holiday Cruise or Cabin Retreat

149. Traditional Christmas or Adventurous Christmas

150. Traveling on Christmas Day or Staying Home

🎨 Décor, Style & Holiday Aesthetic This or That (151–170)

151. Rustic Décor or Glam Décor

152. Neutral Holiday Colors or Bright Holiday Colors

153. Plaid Patterns or Sparkly Patterns

154. Minimalist Christmas or Maximalist Christmas

155. LED Lights or Fairy Lights

156. Real Candles or LED Candles

157. Fresh Pine or Holiday Candle Scent

158. Classic Wrapping Paper or Kraft Paper Wrapping

159. Handmade Ornaments or Store-Bought Ornaments

160. Outdoor Décor or Indoor Décor

161. Single Christmas Tree or Multiple Small Trees

162. Tree Skirt or Tree Collar

163. Wreath on Door or Welcome Sign

164. Traditional Stockings or Themed Stockings

165. Holiday Mugs or Holiday Tumblers

166. Cozy Blankets or Festive Blankets

167. Holiday Pillow Covers or Regular Pillow Covers

168. Snow Globe Décor or Nutcracker Décor

169. Mini Village Display or Train Set Display

170. Metallic Ornaments or Matte Ornaments

🔄 Mixed Holiday & Random Fun This or That (171–200)

171. Early Christmas Music or Late Christmas Music

172. Decorating Before December or Decorating In December

173. Lights Up All December or Lights Up Only Christmas Week

174. Real Tree or Artificial Tree

175. Traditional Holiday Colors or Unconventional Colors

176. Handwritten Cards or Digital Greetings

177. Send Gifts Early or Send Gifts Late

178. Dinner at Home or Dinner Out

179. Movie Night or Game Night

180. Winter Wonderland Theme or Cozy Home Theme

181. Matching Pajamas for Photos or Casual Clothes

182. Holiday Photos or No Photos

183. Secret Santa with Friends or Family

184. Holiday Playlist or Random Music

185. Baking Day or Decorating Day

186. New Traditions or Old Traditions

187. Snowy Photo Background or Christmas Tree Background

188. Real Fireplace or Electric Fireplace

189. Holiday Scented Candles or No Candles

190. Giving Gifts or Giving Time

191. Movie Marathon or Holiday Reading

192. Handmade Cards or Store-Bought Cards

193. Gifts Wrapped or Gifts Bagged

194. Holiday Breakfast or Holiday Dinner

195. Staying Up Late or Sleeping Early

196. Kids Open Gifts First or Adults Open Gifts First

197. Christmas Countdown or No Countdown

198. Secret Letter to Santa or Wish List

199. Holiday Classics Playlist or Holiday Pop Playlist

200. Giving to Charity or Giving Gifts

🎄 Santa, Elves & North Pole This or That (201–220)

201. Santa Suit or Elf Costume

202. Rudolph or Frosty

203. Sleigh Ride or Reindeer Ride

204. Santa Cookies or Santa Milk

205. Naughty List or Nice List

206. North Pole or South Pole

207. Working as an Elf or Working as a Reindeer Trainer

208. Santa with a List or Santa with a Tablet

209. Traditional Santa Suit or Modern Santa Suit

210. Santa’s Workshop or Elf Village

211. Toy-Making Elves or Cookie-Making Elves

212. Reindeer Games or Elf Games

213. Santa Down the Chimney or Santa Through the Door

214. Santa’s Sleigh or Santa’s Magic Portal

215. Snowy North Pole or Northern Lights North Pole

216. Named Reindeer or No-Named Reindeer

217. Rudolph with Red Nose or Rudolph Without Glow

218. Milk and Cookies or Hot Chocolate and Cookies

219. Uniform Elves or Mismatched Elves

220. Santa’s Bag or Santa’s Workshop Magic

💫 Holiday Lifestyle & Final Fun This or That (221–250)

For a quieter or more meaningful activity, include Christmas Bible trivia questions and answers to bring a traditional and reflective twist to the fun.

221. Cozy Cabin Christmas or City Christmas

222. Rustic Décor or Modern Chic Décor

223. Winter Photography or Holiday Videography

224. Reading by the Fireplace or Watching TV by the Fireplace

225. Real Candles or Battery Candles

226. Fresh Pine Décor or Faux Pine Décor

227. Holiday Market Trip or Online Holiday Shopping

228. Christmas Puzzles or Christmas Board Games

229. Staying in Pajamas All Day or Dressing Up

230. Snow Globe Collecting or Ornament Collecting

231. Hot Chocolate Bar or Snack Bar

232. Red and Gold Theme or Red and White Theme

233. Holiday Brunch or Holiday Dinner

234. Gifts at Midnight or Gifts in Morning

235. Christmas Stockings or No Stockings

236. Baking Cookies or Making Candy

237. Holiday Nail Designs or Holiday Makeup

238. Cozy Socks or Cozy Slippers

239. Apple Cider or Hot Tea

240. Red Ribbon Wrap or Twine and Kraft Paper Wrap

241. Fancy Christmas Dinner or Casual Christmas Dinner

242. Holiday Shopping with Friends or Shopping Alone

243. Holiday Scented Soap or Regular Soap

244. Christmas Countdown Apps or Paper Advent Calendar

245. Wearing Holiday Jewelry or No Holiday Jewelry

246. Spending Christmas in Nature or Spending Christmas in City

247. Ornament Swap or Cookie Swap

248. Watching Holiday Parades or Watching Holiday Movies

249. Cooking a Big Feast or Ordering Out

250. Staying Offline or Posting Festive Photos

Whether you use these Christmas This or That questions at a family gathering, classroom party, office celebration, or a cozy night in, they’re guaranteed to spark fun conversations, create new memories, and bring everyone a little closer together. The holidays are all about connection, and sometimes all it takes is choosing between hot cocoa or eggnog to get people smiling.

Feel free to mix them into games, add them to Christmas cards, share them on social media, or use them as festive icebreakers throughout the season. Wishing you a joyful, cozy, laughter-filled Christmas, and may all your “this or that” choices be merry and bright! 🎄✨